It's a moot point Delmon Young is our starting left fielder for the foreseeable future!

So deal with it!...

There both not that good out there, Zamboni. Sorry, yes I was speaking of Young Mr. Young. Time will tell on this guy. There was a reason he was traded to us in the first place. If was a betting man, I would say 1 year more or he may be trade bait this winter.

G.C.

well, Manny actually did better fielder for the Sox

G GS INN TC [PoorWordUsage] A E DP FPCT
sox 66 66 537 106 99 6 1 2 .991
dodgers 53 53 436 94 91 1 2 0 .979

may seem like he did bad out there, but stats don't lie and had a good fielding percentage

But, i'm sticking with my liking of Young, and i'm not going to change your mind. But if your willing to give him up, then makes your saying giving up Garza, Barlett, Young, Eduardo Morlan, for Casey Blake or Beltre? wow, love for you to be a GM, probably related to MILLAn, if making stupdi moves like that

Jigger I agree with you that Young wis a decent outfielder. He does scare me though with the late breaks he gets.

As far as Manny goes his fielding percentage looks good because he gives very little effort to get to alot of balls. It doesn't get scored an error if it drops in, even if it was a fly that could have been caught with a little effort.

most outfield errors occur on throws not drops.

Manny is Manny and what you get is what you see A SHOW OFF. He thinks his stuff don't stink. I lost all respect for the guy, when he caught that ball and gave a fan a high five after he caught it. Yes it was a good catch and he did double off the runner. However showoffs are just that showoffs and are NOT team players. He plays for himself. LOOK AT ME LOOK AT ME. I am great with all my hair flowing so nicely.
Last I checked there is no I in team.

Sorry, just don't like the guy the way he is now. Clean up your hair and start playing like a team player, then you might be someone.

G.C.

There is a "ME" for him, and you must have watched lately, but he is playing team game with the dodgers, and he has cut his hair. and look how there are, up 2-0 with the cubs. he must be good if he's the leader for homeruns in post season history, i believe he's the one who got the Sox and Dodgers to the play-offs and world series.

I am not saying he is a bad player. He can play the game. He is just not a team player. It has been said he is trouble in the clubhouse. By the way where is Boston this post season without Manny.

G.C.

well, got money and other replacements for him, thats why there in there.

I personally think our best option is one of these 2 ways:

RF- Cuddyer
CF- Gomez
LF-Span
DH- Young.

Hate to move Span, but I think he is more than capable anywhere out there, and Cuddyer is a weapon in RF with that arm, we have all seen that.

Platoon Kubel and Young out to the OF to spell the 3 starters.


And the other option is to sign an OF'er, then figure out where to put everyone.

I don't honestly want to give up on Young, esp given his age, but his defense in the OF is horrible.

IF you get rid of anyone, Kubel has to be the consensus. Not a great defensive player, major knee reconstruction, left handed, probably shown you what he really is.

You DON'T get rid of Gomez, Young or Span because they have shown some amazing potential and they are really young.

Span can play anywhere in the outfield and play it well above average.

I think you keep Cuddy, Gomez, Span and Young. Use Young as your primary DH and rotate him with Cuddy and the others to get them a day off in the field.

delmon plays left field like his brother, but did hit way better after the first couple months.

delmon was originally a right fielder. if anything if it changes it should be:

LF-Span
CF-Gomez
RF-Young-covers the same ground as cuddy but makes cuddys cannon arm look like shannon stewart's arm
DH-Cuddy (actually cuddy should be at third or moved)

if he loses a few pounds and listens to the great coachs we have then look out. Remember a few years ago when this kid threw a bat at an ump and everyone said this kid is going no where fast?