Minnesota Fishing Wisconsin Outdoors
HotSpotOutdoors.com

Fishing Minnesota
Fishing Wisconsin

"We Have More Fun"
Before Posting ANY - web address, commercial contact info, e-mail addresses or commercial pictures please Click Here for more information.
To get authorization to post for items or services wanted, or for sale items please Click Here
.
We insist that posts follow Forum Policy. Be sure to read it before posting. Thanks much.
Please keep your posts fun, friendly, and sharing with good family values.
You've Found the Best Outdoor Members on the Net Right here. Enjoy!


Register HereForum Policy - Please, you must read before using this forum. Thanks!Fishing Minnesota
Who's Online
413 Registered (18 inch Crappie, 1900_LE, 311Hemi, 46° - 94° Angler, 4wanderingeyes, 50inchpig, 38 invisible), 822 Guests
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Outdoor Pro Store


On The Forums ...
Any carvers out there?
by shamalex72
0 seconds ago
Mille Lacs tomorrow...
by Slow Rollin
3 minutes 45 seconds ago
HELP! onboard charger acting up
by Northlander
3 minutes 50 seconds ago
Flash question
by fishinchicks
4 minutes 59 seconds ago
What is this?????
by paceman
5 minutes 12 seconds ago
Life is Good!
by rcook72
6 minutes 40 seconds ago
White Bear Muskies
by SSMinner
11 minutes 32 seconds ago
Single pin sight
by sticknstring
14 minutes 12 seconds ago
All Obama, McCain & VP Posts go Here
by Big Tom
15 minutes 21 seconds ago
Home Building Prices/Materials?
by Roofer
17 minutes 11 seconds ago
Newest Members
pros kid, ssr, walleye08, briarthorn, SORNO
39473 Registered Users
Top daily posters:
Sandmannd 28
mrklean 24
dtro 22
Loos15 20
Northlander 16
fishwater 14
harvey lee 14
shackbash 14
stfcatfish 13
Bass N Spear 13
Forum Stats
185 Forums
179031 Topics
1510468 Posts

Max Online: 3699 @ 05/13/08 12:57 PM
Page 3 of 3 < 1 2 3
Topic Options
#1465475 - 07/18/08 04:27 PM Re: big fish ...keep it or not ? [Re: harvey lee]
KMR85 Online   content
Sr FishingMN Family

Registered: 12/07/06
Posts: 331
Loc: Mounds View, MN
that is correct. somehow i think that people will not realize this until the resources are gone.
_________________________
kyle.roepke@comcast.net


Top
#1465483 - 07/18/08 04:38 PM Re: big fish ...keep it or not ? [Re: 7outof10]
Muddog Offline
Sr FishingMN Family

Registered: 04/15/05
Posts: 1085
Loc: LeSueur Co,
I throw all fish back. If you ask me, they all taste fishy. sick The only ones that come home with me are the ones that don't make it. No live bait for me thank you very much.

What I don't care for is the idea that once the Walleyes get to 19.5" some people think they have to get them all before they reach 20" because then you can only keep one!

Top
#1465530 - 07/18/08 05:24 PM Re: big fish ...keep it or not ? [Re: 7outof10]
Team Otter Moderator Online   content
HotSpotOutdoors Pro Staff

Registered: 02/14/02
Posts: 7652
Loc: Le Sueur, MN USA
Keep it. That's why it's a "trophy".
_________________________
Tight Lines,
Jamison Vanden Einde
www.TightLinesGuiding.com

Fishing Minnesota Sponsors

Top
#1465833 - 07/19/08 08:36 AM Re: big fish ...keep it or not ? [Re: Team Otter]
james_walleye Offline
Sr IceLeaders Family

Registered: 01/24/01
Posts: 1742
Loc: Rochester, MN, US
Biologically speaking it doesnt hurt any lake to take a walleye over about 28" out of it. They have done their thing by then and eggs out of say a 30" fish are for the most part not viable. That is why you will see a top on end lake slot end at 26" or 28". Fish over that length on that lake are past prime. Now i'm not saying keep every 27" walleye because they have done their thing biologically. Obviously your 27" one day could be someones 29" fish in a couple years. I caught a 30 3/4" fish out of Madison in 1994 and its on my wall and i look at it every day. If i was ever fortunate enough to get an honest 31" i would probably do the same, but lets face it, they don't come around to often and there is a good chance i'll never have to make that decision. I dont have a problem with people keeping a trophy for the wall. And yeah you'll find the person once in a while who puts a bunch on the wall but not very often.

Top
#1465840 - 07/19/08 08:53 AM Re: big fish ...keep it or not ? [Re: wishing for walleyes]
da_chise31 Online   content
HotSpotOutdoors Specialist

Registered: 05/31/04
Posts: 3293
Loc: Lesser Minnesota
Originally Posted By: wishing for walleyes
Reading through all the posts on this topic makes me think...What can be done in these southern lakes so these walleyes can reproduce better.How can better habitat be acheived in these shallow lakes?Not at all thrying to change the subject or hijack this post.Only looking to further the discussion.


Very little in some instances.

Some of the lakes never held walleye historically.

For those that did, the best things that can be done are landscape/watershed level changes to maintain and improve water quality. The biggest thing is protection of spawning habitat. When everyone and their neighbor chooses to rip out shoreline vegetation, rip rap the banks, and stick mondo-huge docks out, they destroy the most important habitat in the lake. Now you're reading that and thinking "but walleyes don't need aquatic vegetation to spawn like perch, pike, bass, or sunfish, they are pelagic broadcast egg layers." That is true, but think about all the runoff that comes into that lake from that property. Nutrients change the water chemistry and water clarity. Silt dumps into the water, covering the little gravel bar walleyes spawn over. Vegetation where larval and juvenile fish hang out for protection is removed daily by a weed roller, eliminating more habitat. Protection of water edges are very important for all fish, as are changes further up in the watershed.
_________________________
Fish Hard or Go Home!

FishingMN Sponsors
HSO Arctic Armor - I Got Mine Here.

Top
#1466121 - 07/19/08 07:50 PM Re: big fish ...keep it or not ? [Re: da_chise31]
Team Otter Moderator Online   content
HotSpotOutdoors Pro Staff

Registered: 02/14/02
Posts: 7652
Loc: Le Sueur, MN USA
Thanks for sharing your knowledge Scott.
_________________________
Tight Lines,
Jamison Vanden Einde
www.TightLinesGuiding.com

Fishing Minnesota Sponsors

Top
#1472817 - 07/26/08 11:29 PM Re: big fish ...keep it or not ? [Re: james_walleye]
wanger29 Offline
Sr FishingMN Family

Registered: 12/30/05
Posts: 501
Loc: Austin
Just curious, what's the size of the one on your avatar?


Edited by wanger29 (07/26/08 11:29 PM)
_________________________
<*}}}><(

Top
#1473289 - 07/27/08 08:21 PM Re: big fish ...keep it or not ? [Re: wanger29]
Team Otter Moderator Online   content
HotSpotOutdoors Pro Staff

Registered: 02/14/02
Posts: 7652
Loc: Le Sueur, MN USA
That's from Dogtooth; it doesn't count. Ha!
_________________________
Tight Lines,
Jamison Vanden Einde
www.TightLinesGuiding.com

Fishing Minnesota Sponsors

Top
#1480102 - 08/03/08 06:50 PM Re: big fish ...keep it or not ? [Re: Team Otter]
james_walleye Offline
Sr IceLeaders Family

Registered: 01/24/01
Posts: 1742
Loc: Rochester, MN, US
sorry i was on vacation, it was 28 1/2" and yeah it was dogtooth.

Top
Page 3 of 3 < 1 2 3
Topic Options

Moderator:  luckycrank, Team Otter 
Hot Spot Outdoors


Ice Leaders Sponsors


Support our Sponsors